News ID: 275090
Published: 1112 GMT October 04, 2020

Memo to the UK Home Office: A little humanity goes a long way

Memo to the UK Home Office: A little humanity goes a long way

A general view of Ascension Island in the Atlantic Ocean

By Kenan Malik*

Dump them on Ascension Island. Or in Moldova. Imprison them in disused ferries. Build “marine fences” across the (English) Channel. Deploy water cannons to make huge waves to swamp their boats.

And so it goes on. All apparently ideas from Home Office “brainstorming” sessions on how to deal with asylum seekers and cross-Channel undocumented migrants.

There is little new about many of these ideas. In 1987, Margaret Thatcher’s government put Tamil asylum seekers on an old ship in Harwich. In 2004, Tony Blair offered Tanzania an extra £4 million aid if it would build an “asylum camp” for Somalis seeking refuge in Britain. The previous year, the then home secretary, David Blunkett, had floated the idea of using offshore holding centers, a proposal welcomed by the EU.

It was Australia that pioneered policies of “offshoring” asylum seekers with its notorious camps on Manus and Nauru. And it has been the EU that has taken such policies to another level. Home Secretary Priti Patel is following a long, sordid tradition.

The brainstorming ideas are more about spectacle than solutions. Despite the hysteria over cross-Channel migrants, the numbers of asylum seekers are lower this year (largely because of COVID-19). The real crisis is in the response — the failure to assess claims quickly enough, the creation of a huge backlog, thousands being locked up for months on end.

But Patel wants to be seen to be doing something. And that means branding migrants as so unwelcome they cannot set foot in this country.

But here’s a thought for the next Home Office brainstorm. How about treating migrants as human beings and, as economist Jonathan Portes put it, processing asylum claims quickly and humanely? Less of a spectacle, but it might even work.


* This article, by columnist Kenan Malik, was first published in the Guardian.




Security Key:
Captcha refresh
Page Generated in 0/1185 sec